800 sq ft attic in Texas
Zone 2, uninsulated, closing the gap to R-38
$1,740 to $2,360
Saves about $240/yr · pays back in 8.6 years
Attic · R-value, material and cost
The single highest-return insulation project in almost every US home. Heat rises, and an under-insulated attic bleeds it straight through the roof.
Total estimated cost
$2,370to$3,200
Midpoint $2,784 · range reflects local pricing and site conditions
| Item | Cost |
|---|---|
| Blown-In Cellulose material8.6 in to close an R-30 gap over 1,200 sq ft | $1,440 |
| Waste allowance10% overage for trimming and irregular framing | $144 |
| Installation laborthe national average rate (1.00x national) | $1,200 |
| Estimated total | $2,784 |
Estimated energy savings
$63per year
Pays back in 44.2 years
Cooling savings are priced at 17.0¢/kWh, the US average residential electricity rate. Uses 4,600 heating and 1,100 cooling degree days for zone 4.
This models heat conduction through the assembly only. It excludes air leakage and duct losses, which in an older house are frequently larger than conduction, so real savings are often higher than this figure, and it is a planning estimate rather than an energy audit.
Same job, other materials
The DOE recommendation for this assembly changes substantially across the country. This is why a single national figure is not useful.
| Climate zone | Recommended R-value | Typical states | Dominant load |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zone 1 | R-30 | hottest zone in the country | cooling |
| Zone 2 | R-38 | Gulf Coast and desert Southwest | cooling |
| Zone 3 | R-38 | lower South and much of coastal California | cooling |
| Zone 4 | R-49 | mid-Atlantic | mixed |
| Zone 5 | R-49 | lower Midwest | heating |
| Zone 6 | R-49 | upper Midwest and northern New England | heating |
| Zone 7 | R-49 | Alaska and the coldest interior northern counties | heating |
Select your state in the calculator above and the correct zone and target are applied automatically.
The same assembly across three climate zones, showing how much the zone changes both the target and the payback.
Zone 2, uninsulated, closing the gap to R-38
$1,740 to $2,360
Saves about $240/yr · pays back in 8.6 years
Zone 5, R-19 existing, topping up to R-49
$2,370 to $3,210
Saves about $81/yr · pays back in 34.4 years
Zone 6, R-11 existing, topping up to R-49
$3,510 to $4,750
Saves about $263/yr · pays back in 15.7 years
Only the materials that genuinely suit this assembly, priced for 1,200 sq ft going from R-19 to R-49.
| Material | R / inch | Depth needed | Total cost | Air sealing | DIY? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fiberglass Batt | R-3.2 | 9.4 in | $2,456 | None | Yes |
| Blown-In Cellulose | R-3.5 | 8.6 in | $2,784 | Moderate | Yes |
| Blown-In Fiberglass | R-2.5 | 12.0 in | $3,101 | None | Yes |
| Open-Cell Spray Foam | R-3.7 | 8.1 in | $6,616 | Excellent | No |
| Closed-Cell Spray Foam | R-6.5 | 4.6 in | $9,471 | Excellent | No |
Start here. In nearly every climate zone the attic returns more per dollar than any other assembly, and it is the easiest to access.
The single highest-return insulation project in almost every US home. Heat rises, and an under-insulated attic bleeds it straight through the roof.
Insulating 1,200 square feet of attic from R-19 to the zone 4 recommendation of R-49 costs $2,370 to $3,200 installed at national-average rates, roughly $2.32 per square foot, and saving about $63 a year. Your climate zone changes the target substantially: the same assembly needs R-38 in zone 2 and R-49 in zone 6, so the same house costs meaningfully more to bring up to standard in the north.
Priority: Start here. In nearly every climate zone the attic returns more per dollar than any other assembly, and it is the easiest to access.
Work from the gap rather than the area. Take your zone's target, R-49 for attic insulation in zone 4, subtract the R-value already in place, and divide what is left by the material's R per inch. Closing an R-30 gap takes 8.6 inches of blown-in cellulose, 9.4 inches of fiberglass batt or 4.6 inches of closed-cell foam.
Turning depth into material is the last step. Blown-in is sold by the bag against a coverage chart that falls as depth rises, one bag covers 32 square feet at R-30 but only about 20 at R-49, so 1,200 square feet at R-49 works out to roughly 62 bags. Batts are sold by the package at 40 to 49 square feet each, and rigid foam in 32-square-foot sheets.
Enter your square feet in the calculator above and it does all of this from your state, the zone lookup, the target, the gap, the depth and the installed cost, without an email address or a signup.
Not every material suits every assembly. For attic, the realistic options are fiberglass batt, blown-in fiberglass, blown-in cellulose, open-cell spray foam, closed-cell spray foam.
Fiberglass Batt delivers R-3.2 per inch at about $0.15 per square foot per inch, which puts this job at $2,456. Cheapest material per R-value and available everywhere, though performance collapses if compressed or poorly fitted. It is realistically DIY-installable.
Blown-In Fiberglass delivers R-2.5 per inch at about $0.12 per square foot per inch, which puts this job at $3,101. Fills irregular cavities and around obstructions well, though lowest r per inch of any option, so it needs real depth. It is realistically DIY-installable.
Blown-In Cellulose delivers R-3.5 per inch at about $0.14 per square foot per inch, which puts this job at $2,784. Best R per inch of the affordable materials, though settles roughly 10-20% over time unless dense-packed. It is realistically DIY-installable.
R-value per inch matters most when depth is constrained. In an open attic you can simply add depth, so cost per R-value wins. In a 2x4 wall cavity or a shallow crawl space you have a fixed 3.5 inches to work with, and closed-cell spray foam's R-6.5 per inch is the only way to reach a high target, which is exactly why it costs what it does.
An open attic floor is the one place in the house where depth is nearly free, which changes the material calculation completely. Cost per R-value wins, and that points at blown-in cellulose or fiberglass batt: $2,784 and $2,456 respectively for the reference job above, against $9,471 for closed-cell spray foam.
Between the two cheap options, installation quality decides it. Batts are cheaper to fit in clean, evenly spaced joist bays and lose most of their rated performance when compressed or gapped around wiring and boxes, failures that are extremely common in real installations. Run the blown in insulation calculator setting instead and the material flows around every obstruction, which is why it dominates attic retrofits. Cellulose settles roughly 10-20% over the first few years unless dense-packed, so installers blow slightly deep to allow for it.
Two installation details matter more than the product choice. Baffles at the eaves keep material off the soffit vents, because blocking that airflow is how a well-insulated attic ends up with a damp roof deck. And air seal the ceiling plane first, around plumbing stacks, recessed lights, the attic hatch and duct penetrations, because insulation laid over unsealed bypasses hides them rather than fixing them.
Labor is 40-60% of a professional insulation job, so it is the largest single saving on the table: the reference job above drops from $2,784 installed to about $1,704 doing it yourself, including a $120 allowance for blower rental and protective equipment. Most suppliers lend the blower free with a material purchase, which is why blown-in is the most DIY-friendly option despite needing a machine.
Spray foam is the exception and it is not a close call. Professional equipment costs more than the job, and the chemistry is unforgiving of mistakes in mix ratio and substrate temperature. Badly applied foam either fails to cure or shrinks away from the framing, and both are expensive to remove. Kit foam from a big-box store is fine for rim joists and small patches, not for an assembly.
Whatever you use, budget for a respirator, sealed eye protection and long sleeves, work off boards rather than the ceiling drywall, and do the air sealing before the insulation goes down. Once the material is in place you will not want to move it again to find the leaks.
Every figure on this page comes from the same open formula the calculator above uses. We start from your state's DOE climate zone, look up the R-value the Department of Energy recommends for the assembly you are insulating, subtract the R-value already in place, and price only the gap that is left, which is why two houses of identical size get very different numbers. Depth comes from the material's published R per inch, material cost from a 2026 national baseline per square foot per inch, and a 10% allowance is added for trimming and irregular framing. Installed labor is then scaled by the construction earnings multiplier the Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes for your state. The energy saving is a steady-state conduction estimate priced against real US Energy Information Administration residential electricity rates and a national natural gas price, with a 70% realization factor applied. It deliberately excludes air leakage, duct losses and solar gain, so it is a conservative planning figure rather than an energy audit. Nothing is hidden behind a lead form and no contractor pays to appear here. What this is not is a quote: attic access, obstructions, existing damage and any air sealing or venting work are priced separately by whoever does the job.
Insulating 1,200 square feet of attic from R-19 to the zone 4 recommendation of R-49 costs $2,370 to $3,200 installed at national-average rates, about $2.32 per square foot, and saving roughly $63 a year. Fiberglass Batt is the cheapest suitable material for this assembly at $2,456, and closed-cell spray foam the dearest. Your climate zone moves the target substantially, from R-38 in zone 2 to R-49 in zone 6, so the same job costs more to bring up to standard in the north.
Take your zone's target R-value, subtract what is already in place, and divide the remainder by the material's R per inch. For 1,200 sq ft of attic closing an R-30 gap, that is 8.6 inches of blown-in cellulose, or 4.6 inches of closed-cell foam, which matters when the cavity depth is fixed. Multiply the depth by the area for material quantity; the calculator above does all of it from your state and square footage.
It depends entirely on your climate zone. For this assembly the Department of Energy recommends R-30 in zone 1, R-38 in zone 3, R-49 in zone 5 and R-49 in zone 7. Select your state in the calculator above and it applies the correct target automatically. Start here. In nearly every climate zone the attic returns more per dollar than any other assembly, and it is the easiest to access.
Yes, with the right material, fiberglass batt, blown-in fiberglass, blown-in cellulose are realistically DIY-installable here. Doing so removes the labor line, which is 40-60% of a professional insulation job: the reference job above drops from $2,784 to about $1,704. Spray foam is not a DIY material at any scale: the equipment costs more than the job and the chemistry is unforgiving of mistakes in mix ratio and temperature. Budget for a respirator, eye protection and long sleeves whatever you use, and never block soffit vents while you work.
Fiberglass Batt is the cheapest professionally installed option at about $2.05 per square foot on the 1,200 sq ft top-up above, with blown-in cellulose close behind at $2.32. Blown-in costs slightly more to install and performs better around wiring, ducts and irregular framing. DIY is cheaper again at roughly $1,704 for the same attic, because labor is most of the difference and suppliers usually lend the blower free with a material purchase.
About 52 bags of cellulose to reach R-49 from bare joists, which is 14 inches of depth. Bag coverage falls as depth rises, one bag covers 32 sq ft at R-30 but only about 20 sq ft at R-49, which is the single most common reason people run short mid-job. Installed, that attic runs $2,680 to $3,630.
Usually no. R-values add together, so blowing new insulation straight over existing batts is normal practice and gets you to the target for less money than starting again. Remove the old material only where it is genuinely compromised: water-damaged, mold-affected, rodent-contaminated, or vermiculite, which may contain asbestos and needs testing before anyone disturbs it. One detail matters if you are adding batts rather than blown-in, use unfaced batts, because a second vapor barrier partway through the assembly traps moisture between the layers.
Rarely, and almost never by depth alone. Most US homes are still well under the Department of Energy recommendation for their zone. Where excess causes real problems is mechanical rather than thermal: insulation packed over the soffit vents blocks the airflow that keeps the roof deck dry, and a second vapor barrier added partway through an assembly traps moisture inside it. Baffles at the eaves and unfaced material solve both. The more common limit is economic, on a 1,200 sq ft attic, closing an R-0 gap to R-49 saves roughly $610 a year while the last stretch from R-19 saves about $63, so past your zone's recommendation the money almost always does more on air sealing.
Each state page carries its DOE climate zone, R-value targets and local cost guidance.
The figure beside each state is its construction labor multiplier relative to the national average of 1.00×.
Every figure on this page traces back to a published source. Where a government dataset is available, we fetch it at build time rather than typing in a number and hoping it stays true.
Data last updated: August 17, 2026